Is Metal Roofing Right for You? Discover the Pros and Cons
Table of Contents:
If you’re like many homeowners, you’ve probably thought about every aspect of your home’s exterior, from the siding to the type of windows. But what about the roof? It’s a critical part of your home, but choosing the right type can feel like navigating a minefield. So many options, so many factors to consider!
Are you overwhelmed by choices and unsure if metal roofing is suitable for you? At Hershberger Construction, we understand the pressure of making such an important decision for your home, and it’s understandable to feel this way. You deserve a home that looks great and performs even better.
We’ve helped countless homeowners like you navigate these choices and are here to guide you through this process.
This blog post will explore the advantages and disadvantages of metal roofing, empowering you to make an informed choice. We’ll help you determine if it’s the best choice for your home—and we’re confident we can provide the insights you need to make an informed decision.
Benefits of Metal Roofs: Why People Are Making the Switch
Why is metal roofing gaining such popularity? Homeowners are increasingly drawn to it for a variety of practical reasons. Here’s why more and more are making the switch:
- Durability: Unlike traditional asphalt shingles, which typically last 15 to 20 years, the average lifespan of a metal roof ranges from 40 to 70 years.

They can withstand severe weather conditions like high winds, heavy rain, and even hail. Metal roofs are naturally resistant to cracking, curling, and fading. They provide unparalleled protection and peace of mind.
2. Versatility in Design: Metal roofs offer a sleek, modern aesthetic with a variety of color options, styles, and finishes. This allows homeowners to customize their look and match any architectural style.
3. Energy Efficiency: A metal roof can reflect solar radiant heat, keeping your home cooler in the summer and reducing your energy bills by up to 50%. This makes them an attractive option for homeowners hoping to save on energy bills.
4. Lightweight: Metal roofing is significantly lighter than traditional options, which can lead to more straightforward and faster installation processes, minimizing disruption to your daily life. In addition, the lighter weight puts less stress on your home’s structure.
5. Low Maintenance: Metal roofs require minimal attention over their extensive lifespan, freeing your time and resources. Routine inspections for any damage and cleaning to remove debris may be needed, but the overall upkeep is generally easier on time and finances.
6. Environmentally Friendly: They are often made from recycled materials and are entirely recyclable at the end of their lifespan, reducing landfill waste and contributing to a more sustainable building practice.

Plus, their longevity means fewer replacements, further reducing waste and consumption of resources.
7. Long-Term Investment: While the initial metal roofing cost might be higher, the long-term savings on repairs, energy bills, and even potential insurance savings make it a worthwhile investment. You’re looking at a potential lifespan of 50 years or more, a testament to their robust construction and resistance to the elements. This longevity translates to substantial long-term cost savings, reducing the frequency of costly replacements.
8. Fire Resistance: Being non-combustible, metal roofing offers superior fire resistance, often lowering insurance premiums.
These benefits illustrate why so many are saying yes to metal roofs. But what are the possible downsides?
Potential Drawbacks of Metal Roofs
Even with so many positive attributes, metal roofs aren’t perfect. Understanding both sides of the coin helps in making the best decision. Let’s look at some of the possible problems that should be on your radar:
- Cost: One of the main drawbacks of metal roofing is the upfront cost. The initial investment is typically higher than traditional roofing materials like asphalt shingles.

However, this upfront investment is more than offset by the long-term savings and reduced maintenance.
- Noise: Another factor to consider is the potential for increased noise during heavy rain or hail. Without proper insulation, these severe weather events can create noise that might be disruptive to some homeowners. While modern metal roofing technology significantly minimizes this, it’s still a point to be aware of.
- Complex Repairs: Metal roof repairs involve addressing issues like seam separations, corrosion, and punctures. Skilled technicians may be required to seal leaks, replace damaged panels, and ensure proper alignment to extend the roof's lifespan.
- Installation Expertise Needed: Metal roofing requires skilled labor for installation. A poorly installed metal roof can lead to leaks and reduced lifespan.
- Color Matching: If repairs are needed in the future, finding the same color match can be difficult, potentially marring the overall aesthetic.
- Expansion and Contraction: Metal expands and contracts with temperature changes. This can cause fasteners to become loose over time if not properly installed.
- Corrosion: Coastal areas with high salinity or regions with frequent freeze-thaw cycles may necessitate special considerations or protective coatings.
- Aesthetic Concerns: Concerns about metal roofing's aesthetic, like a "shed" look, are common. However, modern metal roofing offers diverse styles, including shingle imitations, ensuring a fit with various home designs. These options alleviate aesthetic worries while providing metal's durability.
- Potential for Dents: Finally, there’s the risk of dents from hail or falling debris. Although high-quality metal roofing is designed to withstand such impacts, they can dent under certain conditions, like a particularly heavy hailstorm.
Careful consideration of these factors is crucial for finding the best roofing option for your needs. Professional installation is key here; ensure you hire experienced roofers to mitigate potential issues.

And while these issues might sound concerning, many are preventable with skilled installation and routine maintenance.
Should You Choose a Metal Roof?
So, how do you determine if metal roofing is the right choice for your home?
- Consider your budget, taking into account both upfront costs and long-term savings.
- Evaluate your local climate and environmental conditions; a metal roof’s resilience is particularly beneficial in regions prone to extreme weather.
- Finally, consider the aesthetic preferences—how well does a metal roof blend with your home’s architecture and surrounding landscape?

Before making a decision, a consultation with a professional roofing contractor is essential to discuss your specific needs and circumstances. They can provide valuable insight into the type of metal roofing best suited for your home and help you make an informed choice.
Conclusion
Metal roofing presents a compelling solution for homeowners seeking a durable, long-lasting, and energy-efficient roofing option. You can decide whether it aligns with your needs and budget by weighing the advantages and potential drawbacks.
We hope this blog has helped you determine whether metal roofing aligns with your needs and priorities. When you’re ready to explore installations or need further guidance, we’re here to help. At Hershberger Construction, we’ve been helping homeowners and business owners improve their properties for over 25 years!

We offer:
- Pole Barns
- Garages
- Timber Frame Homes
- Custom Decks
- … and more!
Check out our other helpful blogs to learn more about some of the services we offer:
- Pole Barns 101
- Pole Barns: Versatile Solutions for Storage, Agriculture, Residential Needs, and Beyond
Contact us today to discuss the best roofing solutions tailored to your home.
Discover the benefits and challenges of metal roofing to decide if it’s the best fit for your home. If metal roofs intrigue you, our team is ready to help you take the next steps.